© 2003-2006 Mike Russell, All Rights Reserved

The Hue Clock: An Overview

The Hue Clock is one of the more exciting features of Curvemeister 2.  It uses our knowledge of how to read a dial clock to provide a quick visual readout of the hue and saturation of a color.   The position of the hand easy to remember, verify, and adjust, and tool that is fast and easy to use will be used more often.

With a little bit of knowledge about the "time" associated with a particular color, the hue clock allows you to assess the correctness of certain colors, including (see figure 1) flesh tones, foliage, and sky, very quickly indeed, and in a quantitative manner

For example, even without special knowledge of the correct hue of an object, it is possible to quickly sweep over an object to check for any systematic hue variations. For example, in figure 2, the sky has more blue near the top of the image, becoming less saturated, and more cyan in color as you move toward the bottom of the image.

Figure 3 shows a photograph of a hawk taken in a common mixed lighting situation: direct sunlight combined with blue sky light. This situation affects almost any outdoor subject, and the amount of blue is related to the brightness of the subject. Using the hue clock it is easy to check for a change in hue angle, and take corrective action. 

With several samples in place, it often a matter of moving the dark endpoint of the blue curve horizontally to make all  the hue clocks show very close to the same reading. Naturally, instead of creating multiple samples, you may choose to drag a single sample around the image.

 


Figure 1. If you can read a one-handed clock, you can remember, for all time, what a reasonable flesh tone, sky, and foliage color look like.

 


Figure 2. The sky varies in hue and saturation

 



Figure 3. The darker feathers of this eagle vary from orange to cyan-blue.
Finding systematic variations in hue are the key to fast, accurate color correction.


Flesh Tone Example  

Figure 3. Before. Not bad, but not
nearly as good as it should be.

Figure 4. After. Notice that in spite of the dramatic change in flesh tone, the rest of the image still looks about the same.
Our brains have very special capabilities for interpreting flesh tones, and if they are a little off, as in Figure 3, it makes an enormous difference in our perception of the health of an individula, and therefore our impression of the image. Professional's know this, and you'll almost always see warm, rich flesh tones in advertising material. With the hue clock, it's much easier make sure this is the case with your own images.

Flesh tones should show a hue angle of approximately 8-15 degrees, or an hour hand position of 12:30 on the hue clock. Think mid lunch hour.  Figure 3 shows a flesh tone from an uncorrected digital camera image - at 10 o'clock, it is much too blue, more of a violet color than a real flesh tone. 

Figure 4 shows a normal flesh tone, in this case corrected via a pinning operation, showing a clock time of about 12:15.  The length of the clock hand is significant - flesh tones should be about the length of a clock's hour hand. Less than that, and the color turns gray. More, and your people will take on an overly orange color.

Instead of pinning, you may use curves manually to bring the Hue clock where it needs to be - just make sure when you are done that the length and position of the Hue clock is approximately that of an hour hand at about 12:30. 12 o'clock is generally too red of a skin tone, and 1 o'clock is too orange/yellow.

Surprisingly, although the hand may point anywhere between 12 and 1 o'clock, the overall darkness or lightness of an individual has very little effect on the position and length of the clock hand.

 

Notes:

  • The small pin icon in the bottom right corner of the palette is used to temporarily disable the pinned color, so that it does not affect the image. Toggling this pin in and out allows you to quickly determine how a given sample changes the curves.
  • With the pin toggled out, the sample will not be obliterated when you click the Reset button in the curve window.
  • You may always double click on the palette to use Photoshop's color picker to modify the sample's targeted color value.
Blue Sky Example  


Figure 5. From left to right, sky with added red, normal sky, and sky with added green.
This example is rather extreme, with only the middle sky being really acceptable.

Figure 5 shows hue clock positions for three different variations on sky color. Most people would know, simply by looking, that something is wrong with the sky on the far left, they might settle for the almost pure cyan sky in the right section of the image.

Pure blue is located at 8 o'clock on the color wheel, and this is reflected in the center sample, . The sky on the left has too much red, and the hue clock's hand has rotated toward 12 o'clock. The rightmost image has had green added, and the hue clock shows a time of about 7 o'clock.

 

The relatively gray granite rock in the lower part of the image shows an obvious red and green color cast for the left and right images, respectively. Neither of these would be acceptable as normal looking stone colors, but the sky colors are more subtly off, and the hue clock is a good visual indicator of this problem, and what direction the clock needs to be rotated to fix it.

As a practical matter, if I were actually correcting the above image, the gray neutral color of the granite would be a more reliable indicator of a color cast than any problems with the sky. But, when such an indicator is absent, or when other manipulations have changed the sky color, remember that, for sky, the hue clock should be at or near 7:30.

Foliage Example  

Figure 6. Plants are generally closer to yellow than they are to green.
In this example, several species of plant are compared.

Next to flesh tones, perhaps we humans are most sensitive to shades of green, and indeed, most of the human sensory color space is devoted to green. Add a bit of yellow to a plant color, and most of us will immediately sense that the plant is suffering some sort of health problem. Add too much blue or green, and the plant takes on an unpleasant, poisonous appearance.

Our reactions, no doubt, go back to prehistory, when the price for eating the wrong thing, or walking all day to a distant hillside that was the wrong color hillside, was very high indeed. (The fact that women are much less likely than men to be color blind may be an indication of whose job it was to find the right plants.)

Plant colors are surprisingly yellow when viewed on the hue clock. In figure 6, the grass, hedge, show a very similar hue and saturation, just after 2 o'clock on the hue clodk. Surprisingly, even the very dark cypress evergreen plant in the upper left of the image comes out at this value. The darker leaves of a camellia plant are the greenest of all, near 3 o'clock, right between yellow and green.

Colors may vary substantially between types of foliage. It is interesting that the underside of a fern, shown in figure 7, although much brighter than the greenery in figure 6, has almost the same hue and saturation as the foliage in the above image. This fact, plus the fact that even slight variations in the color of light can change hue substantially, are fundamentally why pinning works.

Experiment on your own images, and you will find that plant colors start to look bad when they approach pure green or yellow. Very green plants take on a poisonous, plastic look. Yellow or orange foliage looks dead. With very dark colors, the exact hue becomes less important, however a "wrong" green should be heeded, even if it is not very obtrusive, because it may indicate that there are problems with the rest of the image.


Figure 7. The colors in this image of the underside of a fern
indicate a biochemical kinship with the foliage in figure 6.


Table of Contents